Chalk Insurance Agency

Resource · Wildfire HO

HO3 vs. HO5: same house, very different coverage for your stuff

The house is covered about the same. Your stuff isn't.

For: Homeowners comparing quotes, or wondering which form they have

By Tyler Chalk · Published November 10, 2026

Two policies. Same house. Similar price. A very different day when the movers drop your piano.

The short version: On both forms, the house itself is covered about the same way. The difference is your stuff. An HO3 covers your belongings only for 16 named causes, and you have to prove which one happened. An HO5 covers them for anything that isn’t excluded, and the insurance company has to prove the exclusion. It costs more, and how much depends on the house; I’ll show you the exact difference on yours. For most people with nice things, it’s worth it.

First, the red wine

Yes, an HO5 technically covers red wine on the white couch. No, you should not file that claim. In California right now, one small claim can cost you your policy at renewal. Pay for the cleaning. Buy the HO5 for the big ones.

The big ones

What happenedHO3HO5
Rain pours in through an open window, a skylight, or the hole your roofer left mid-jobNot covered. Wind or hail has to make the opening firstCovered
PG&E turns the power back on after a shutoff and the surge fries your electronicsExcludes “electronic components or circuitry”Covered on the standard form (check yours)
The movers drop the pianoNo covered cause. The movers’ basic coverage pays 60 cents a poundCovered, and your carrier goes after the movers
A contractor spills paint or solvent on your rugs, sofa, or artNot coveredCovered, except the thing being refinished
The TV mount fails, or a loaded bookcase tips overNot coveredCovered. Glass, marble, and porcelain are still excluded
A pipe nobody knew was bad bursts behind an upstairs wall, and water pours down to the first floor, ruining the carpet and soaking the woodCovered. A burst pipe is one of the HO3’s named causesCovered
Nobody agrees on what caused a big lossYou have to prove the causeThey have to prove the exclusion

About that piano: at 60 cents a pound, a 700-pound piano is worth $420 to the moving company. As a guy with a music degree, that one hurts.

On the California FAIR Plan, none of the big ones are covered. The FAIR Plan only covers a short list of named perils, mostly fire. That’s it. Without a DIC (a difference in conditions policy, the companion policy that fills in what the FAIR Plan leaves out), the burst pipe, the rain, the piano, all of it is on you.

What the HO5 doesn’t change

Fire and smoke are covered on both forms, so the HO5 buys you nothing extra on the wildfire itself. Flood, earthquake, mold, wear and tear, pests, and your own pets are excluded on both. Jewelry, art, and collectibles still need to be scheduled separately (listed on the policy with their own values). And an HO5 doesn’t automatically mean your stuff is paid at replacement cost, so check how contents are valued.

Here’s the takeaway

My recommendation: if your home qualifies for an HO5, take it. The product name on a quote doesn’t always tell you which form you’re getting, and a cheaper quote on a stripped-down form is a claim problem, not a win. Compare forms first, premium second.

Send me your declarations page. I’ll tell you which form you actually have, and whether the upgrade is worth it for your house.

About the author

Tyler Chalk is an independent P&C insurance producer with over two decades of placement experience, including ten years on the founding team at Embroker. He works independently, placing each client with the agency partner that fits the risk. More about Tyler →

Want to talk about your situation?

If your situation isn't one I can help with, I'll tell you that directly.