Chalk Insurance Agency

Resource · Wildfire HO

Your carrier's calculator is lowballing your house

Underinsure on purpose or build in a cushion. Just don't guess.

For: California homeowners setting or renewing a dwelling limit

By Tyler Chalk · Published November 10, 2026

Quick quiz: what would it cost to rebuild your house? If your answer came from Zillow, this one’s for you.

The short version: Your dwelling limit should be what it costs to rebuild the house, not what it would sell for. The calculators carriers use to set that number usually come in low. You can live with that to save money, or you can fix it. Just decide on purpose.

Replacement cost, in one breath

Replacement cost is what it takes to rebuild from the dirt up at today’s prices: labor, materials, permits, the architect, and hauling away what’s left of the old house. It’s not your market value and it’s not your mortgage. The land doesn’t burn, so it isn’t in there.

The calculator problem

Carriers set your limit with an insurance-to-value calculator, the software that estimates what your house costs to rebuild. It knows your square footage, your year built, and a rough guess at your finishes. It doesn’t know about the custom windows, the hillside foundation, the kitchen you redid in 2021, or what it costs when the city makes you rebuild to today’s code.

In my experience, these calculators usually come in low. They don’t even agree with each other. This year I watched two carriers run the same Lamorinda home and come back about $700,000 apart. Same house. Same month.

Option 1: Save money, eyes open

If the goal is the lowest premium, you can take the carrier’s number and go. You’re probably underinsured, on purpose, and that’s a legitimate choice. Just know two things:

  • On a total loss, the gap is yours. The gap is the difference between your dwelling limit and what the rebuild actually costs. If the rebuild runs $400,000 over your limit, that’s $400,000 out of your pocket. Insuring for that extra $400,000 would likely have cost only a few hundred dollars more a year.
  • Some policies have an 80% coinsurance rule. These tend to be the less desirable policies: often the cheapest option, or the only option in a tough area to place. Coinsurance means that if you’re underinsured, you’re penalized by the percentage you’re short, even on a partial loss. Say the rebuild cost is $1,000,000, so 80% is $800,000. Insure for $600,000 and you’re 25% short, so a $100,000 kitchen fire pays $75,000 before your deductible.

Option 2: Build in a cushion

Or go the other way. You can set your limit above the carrier’s number (within reason; they won’t let you insure a bungalow like a castle) and add extended replacement cost. That’s an extra layer, usually 25% or 50% of your dwelling limit, that kicks in if the rebuild costs more than expected. A $1.5 million limit with 50% extended replacement cost can pay up to $2.25 million to rebuild.

Why bother? After a big fire, every homeowner in the burn area calls every contractor on the same day, and prices go vertical. The industry calls it demand surge. Homeowners call it “wait, how much for drywall?”

Extended replacement cost is a great feature when supply and demand max out in your area. Here’s the catch: it’s an expensive endorsement. Sometimes it makes more sense to skip it and just carry a higher dwelling limit. I’ll price it both ways.

It also usually requires you to insure to 100% of the carrier’s number and to tell them about big remodels. And more limit isn’t a lottery ticket. The carrier pays what the rebuild actually costs, up to your limit, not the limit itself.

Here’s the takeaway

Neither option is wrong. Guessing is. Pricing in the specialty markets I use has eased this year, which makes now a good time to fix a number that’s been low for a while.

Send me your declarations page. I’ll tell you where your number came from and whether I’d trust it.

About the author

Tyler Chalk is an independent P&C insurance producer with over two decades of placement experience, including ten years on the founding team at Embroker. He works independently, placing each client with the agency partner that fits the risk. More about Tyler →

Want to talk about your situation?

If your situation isn't one I can help with, I'll tell you that directly.